Gel eyeliners have become a beloved middle ground between liquid liners and traditional pencil liners for many makeup enthusiasts. They offer the creamy application of a crayon with the precision of a liquid liner, making them an essential tool for achieving that perfect, smudge-proof eye look. What sets gel eyeliners apart is their ability to glide on smoothly, giving users the freedom to blend and fine-tune their look before it sets firmly in place. This characteristic is particularly beneficial for those who enjoy experimenting with their eye makeup, as it allows for different styles without the fear of unsightly smudging throughout the day.
In the world of gel eyeliners, the variety is astounding—there are options available in different formats, from pencils to pots, and an extensive range of shades, finishes, and formulas. Whether you’re seeking a bold black to create a dramatic cat eye or a pop of color for a fun twist, there’s something for everyone. Esteemed makeup artists and beauty editors have weighed in on their favorites, sharing insights on why certain gel eyeliners excel above the rest. From long-lasting wear to easy application, we’ve gathered various opinions and created a curated list of the top gel eyeliners worth trying.
One standout product is the Kulfi Beauty Underlined Kajal Eyeliner, celebrated for its richly pigmented formula that glides on effortlessly. Priced at $20, this eyeliner is infused with vitamin E and aloe vera, which helps it smooth over the skin while also nourishing it. Makeup artist Amrita Mehta swears by this formula; she notes that it sets quickly after application, allowing for smudging without the worry of fading. Tester Jen Hussein praises its performance, sharing that she achieves a long-lasting look by preparing her waterline prior to application. For those looking for a reliable eyeliner that offers both stunning color payoff and versatility, this Kajal is certainly worth considering.
For those in search of the perfect black eyeliner, Pat McGrath Labs’ PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil comes highly recommended. At $29, this pencil is not only easy to use but also boasts a long-lasting formula that holds up for up to eight hours—even on the waterline. Commerce producer Sarah Hoffmann touts the eyeliner’s ability to create a spectrum of looks, from a subtle tightline to a bold smoky eye. With its smooth application and variety of finishes, whether matte or pearlescent, this gel pencil proves itself to be a must-have for those who desire versatility in their eye makeup.
The Jones Road Gel Liner, priced at $32, represents a unique option as it comes in a pot rather than a pencil. This packaging encourages a more artistic application, and when paired with a good brush, the results can be both precise and dramatic. Content Director Kara McGrath highlights its creamy consistency, which makes it an excellent choice for beginners as it’s forgiving and manageable. For those who are just starting out with gel eyeliners, this product is a fantastic introduction, allowing users to build their skills without the risk of unfortunate mishaps.
If you’re looking for something that stands up to tears and sweat, the Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Gel Eyeliner, priced at $24, is a premier waterproof option. Its deep pigmentation and lasting wear make it ideal for those active days where you want your eye makeup to stay intact. Equally impressive is Bobbi Brown’s Long-Wear Smudge-Proof Gel Eyeliner, which retails for $36. As the name suggests, this liner promises to stay in place without smudging, providing a clean, sharp line that can transition seamlessly from day to night.
Finally, for those with sensitive eyes, the Ilia Clean Line Gel Eyeliner at $26 is designed to be gentle yet effective. This eyeliner is formulated with clean ingredients, ensuring that it’s less likely to irritate the eyes, making it a go-to option for sensitive skin types. The L’Oréal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner is another great pick, particularly for those watching their budget, coming in at only $11 while still delivering impressive quality.
In summary, every makeup lover can find a gel eyeliner that suits their style, skin type, and preferences from this selection of top contenders. With the right tools and a little practice, achieving beautiful, defined eyes has never been easier. Whether you lean towards vibrant colors or classic blacks, gel eyeliners promise to elevate your eye looks while ensuring longevity and performance. Happy lining!