Whether you’re a makeup novice experimenting with winged eyeliner or on the verge of becoming the next beauty influencer thanks to TikTok trends, having the right eyeliner is crucial for achieving that flawless look you’ve been dreaming about. With a range of options available, from precise liquid liners to luscious gel eyeliners, the best products on the market share a common goal: transforming your eye makeup into a masterpiece that lasts all day and night. We consulted industry experts, makeup artists, and dermatologists to identify the top eyeliners that deliver on quality, reliability, and the potential to become your go-to choice. Here’s a look at our top selections, alongside insights into what makes each of them truly special.
One standout option is the Kulfi Beauty Underlined Kajal Eyeliner, which has earned its place as our best overall eyeliner. Priced at $20, this innovative product draws inspiration from traditional kajal—a richly pigmented eyeliner that has been cherished in South Asian culture. With a buttery texture and vibrant pigmentation, it glides on effortlessly and sets without smudging, making it ideal for both tightlining and creating smoky looks. Jennifer Hussein, a commerce writer for Allure, praises its ease of use and effectiveness, stating, “Just a few quick strokes are all I need to define my eyes.” For those looking for enhanced longevity, a simple tip is to prep the waterline with a Q-tip before application, ensuring your eyeliner stays sleek and budge-proof throughout the day.
For those who prioritize waterproof formulas, the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is our best waterproof pick at $24. Esteemed for its felt-tip design, this liquid liner allows for flexibility in application—whether you’re aiming for defined wings or smooth lines, its versatile tip accommodates both styles. According to Allure contributing editor Deanna Pai, the robust construction allows for smooth application without skipping or tugging on the lid, and the long-lasting matte finish holds up against sweat and tears. This liner has become a staple for many, embodying reliability that accompanies you from morning till night without the need for continuous touch-ups.
If precision is your primary concern, look no further than the Chanel Le Liner de Chanel Liquid Eyeliner, which retails for $42. Known for its luxurious branding, Chanel delivers with a latex-based formula that provides both depth of color and remarkable staying power. Its tapered tip allows for meticulous application, making it a favorite among those who demand clean lines and defined edges. Commerce producer Sarah Hoffmann notes its stiff applicator, which grants her the control needed for a perfected wing, minimizing the risk of mistakes. The unique shades available, including the sophisticated Rouge Noir, elevate this eyeliner to a level of artistic expression when paired with complementary eye makeup.
Diving into the realm of colors, the Valentino Colorgraph Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, priced at $38, stands out as our best pick for colorful eyeliner. Whether you’re looking to add a pop of color to your everyday look or create a bold statement, this gel pencil glides on smoothly, allowing for versatile styles from precise lines to blended finishes. The waterproof formula ensures that these vibrant hues stay put, making them a great choice for adventurous makeup play. The joy of experimentation is further encouraged with this eyeliner, letting you play with your look while maintaining confidence in staying power.
Another favorite in the gel category is the Jones Road Gel Liner which retails for $32. This gel formula stands out for its ease of application, allowing for a range of looks from natural to dramatic with minimal effort. Its creamy consistency means it glides on easily, while still providing enough staying power to endure throughout the day without fading or smudging. Whether you’re an eyeliner novice or a seasoned pro, the versatility and reliability of this gel liner can seamlessly fit into any makeup routine, making it an exceptional choice that complements various styles.
Finally, for those looking to splurge on a top-tier eyeliner, the Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof Liner at $73 is the ultimate indulgence. This luxurious eyeliner combines an ultra-precise application with high-quality ingredients designed to nourish the delicate eye area. Users rave about its ability to deliver deep, rich pigmentation without sacrificing comfort, and the waterproof formula ensures flawless wear. Investing in quality eyeliner enhances not only your makeup routine but also the health and appearance of your skin—making this Sisley liner worth every penny for those who appreciate the finer things in beauty.
Selecting the right eyeliner can make a profound difference in your overall makeup look, whether simple and understated or bold and expressive. As you explore your options, consider the various formulations and features that best align with your needs. With this curated guide to top eyeliners, you’re well-equipped to find the perfect match to create stunning looks that last from dawn to dusk, all while catering to your unique style preferences. Embrace this journey of finding your ideal liner, and let your eyes do the talking!